Beneath the Headline | Edition 007
The human impact behind the business story.
The Headline
Qualcomm is preparing to eliminate jobs globally following its annual employee performance reviews.
According to an October 20 Reuters report, CEO Cristiano Amon informed employees that the company would undertake a performance-focused workforce reduction intended to strengthen its performance culture and address persistent underperformance. The company has not disclosed how many employees will be affected, and its decisions will also consider business priorities, organizational needs, and the skills required for future growth.
There's nothing unusual about organizations considering employee performance when making employment decisions. Companies establish expectations, employees are responsible for meeting them, and sometimes separation is appropriate.
But what caught my attention was the connection between annual performance reviews and a broader workforce reduction. It made me think about how much weight organizations place on evaluations that are often conducted formally just once a year, particularly when the outcome may affect someone's continued employment.
And it raises a question I think deserves more attention: How much confidence should executives place in a performance rating without understanding everything that contributed to it?
Beneath the Headline
I found something interesting in Qualcomm's 2025 Corporate Responsibility Report. The company describes a performance-management approach that includes clear objectives, ongoing conversations between employees and managers, and feedback from multiple sources. It recommends that managers conduct performance conversations at least every six months, in addition to annual evaluations.
That's important context. Qualcomm's publicly described approach recognizes that managing performance is an ongoing responsibility. And we don't have enough information about its individual employment decisions to conclude that the company hasn't followed that approach.
But it does make me think about what happens inside organizations when performance concerns continue despite having established processes intended to address them.
If an employee has been struggling for months, what has happened during that time? Has the manager addressed the concern? Does the employee understand where they're falling short? Has leadership examined whether expectations are clear and whether employees have what they need to meet them?
And when an organization identifies a broader pattern of underperformance, shouldn't executives also be asking what those results reveal about the organization itself?
Certainly, employees are responsible for meeting reasonable expectations. But when performance deficiencies extend beyond isolated cases, I think leadership has a responsibility to examine whether something in the organization is contributing to those outcomes. That could include inconsistent management practices, unclear priorities, inadequate resources, or expectations that haven't kept pace with changing business conditions.
An organization can have a well-designed performance-management process and still struggle with how consistently that process is carried out.
A performance review should reflect a year of performance management. It should never be mistaken for the entirety of it.
The annual evaluation should bring together what an employee has already been hearing throughout the year. It should reflect ongoing conversations, documented observations, and a reasonable understanding of the employee's contributions and deficiencies.
And if those conversations haven't been happening, I think executives should question how much confidence they can place in the final assessment.
The question its announcement raises is broader than Qualcomm: How do executives know whether their performance-management systems are producing assessments reliable enough to support consequential decisions?
The Human Impact
I once advised an organization that was determined to terminate an employee for performance. Leadership had concerns about the employee's ability to meet expectations, and the conversation was moving toward separation. But there was another issue I kept raising. The employee's manager had significant performance deficiencies of their own.
The organization acknowledged those concerns. Leadership agreed that the manager's effectiveness was a problem. Yet the focus remained on the employee's shortcomings, and the organization ultimately proceeded with termination.
What concerned me was how difficult it was to separate the employee's performance from the conditions under which that performance had occurred.
When a manager struggles to communicate expectations, provide direction, address obstacles, or offer meaningful feedback, those deficiencies can directly affect the people reporting to them. An employee may genuinely be struggling to perform, but how do we determine how much of that struggle is attributable to the employee and how much may have been influenced by the manager?
And if the organization already knows that the manager has performance deficiencies, shouldn't that influence how much weight it gives the manager's assessment of someone else?
I want to be clear that an ineffective manager doesn't automatically excuse an employee's failure to meet expectations. Employees have responsibilities, and there are circumstances where termination is justified regardless of a manager's shortcomings.
But when an organization recognizes deficiencies in the person responsible for evaluating an employee, I believe that should prompt additional examination before a consequential employment decision is made. Otherwise, how can leadership be confident that it's evaluating the employee's performance accurately?
This is where I think the human impact becomes particularly significant. An employee may lose their livelihood based on an assessment that doesn't fully account for the circumstances influencing their performance. And the organization may continue operating with the same managerial deficiencies that contributed to the problem.
The employee is gone, but the underlying issue may remain.
Before It Becomes Your Headline
Performance evaluations are useful. They help organizations recognize contributions, identify development needs, inform compensation and advancement decisions, and document whether expectations are being met. But I would caution executives against allowing a rating to carry more authority than the process behind it deserves.
Before relying heavily on annual evaluations to make employment decisions, there are three things I would encourage leadership teams to examine.
1. What evidence supports the rating?
A performance rating should be supported by specific observations, documented results, and a clear understanding of the expectations the employee was responsible for meeting. Executives should be cautious when ratings rely heavily on general impressions or when employees are receiving feedback they haven't previously heard.
It's also worth examining whether managers apply performance standards consistently. The same rating may reflect very different expectations or levels of performance across teams.
2. What conditions influenced the employee's performance?
Employees don't perform in isolation. Their ability to meet expectations can be influenced by leadership decisions, available resources, competing priorities, and the clarity of the direction they receive.
If an organization has concerns about a manager's effectiveness, those concerns should be considered when evaluating the performance of employees reporting to that manager. And if multiple employees within the same team are struggling, executives should examine whether there are shared conditions contributing to those outcomes.
3. How has the organization validated the assessment?
Before an evaluation influences someone's continued employment, leadership should be confident that the information has been appropriately reviewed. That may involve examining the employee's performance history, challenging inconsistencies between ratings, and considering information beyond a single manager's assessment.
The purpose isn't to eliminate managerial judgment. It's to ensure that judgment is supported by reliable evidence and considered in the context of the employee's actual working conditions.
These questions become even more important when organizations use performance ratings to compare employees across departments or inform workforce reductions. A standardized rating scale doesn't automatically mean every employee has been evaluated under comparable circumstances. And when the consequences are significant, the quality of the assessment matters just as much as the rating itself.
The Closing Thought
Performance reviews have an important place in organizations. But I wonder whether we've become so accustomed to relying on them that we sometimes give the final rating more consideration than the process that produced it.
An employee's performance is influenced by many factors, including their own decisions and capabilities, the expectations established for them, and the leadership they receive. When an evaluation is used to make a decision about someone's continued employment, all of those factors deserve consideration.
I would encourage executives to look beyond the ratings presented during annual review season. Examine what those ratings reveal about the organization, the consistency of its performance-management practices, and the accountability of the managers responsible for carrying them out.
A performance review may tell you how an employee was evaluated. It doesn't necessarily tell you how effectively that employee was managed.
And when someone's livelihood is at stake, I believe that distinction deserves more attention.
Before you allow a performance rating to determine someone's future with your organization, have you examined whether their manager met the expectations of theirs?
Stay Human,
LaShawn Davis
About the Author
LaShawn Davis is the Founder and CEO of The HR Plug, an employee and labor relations advisory firm, and the creator of The UNPLUG Experience. Drawing on her experience advising organizations and leading employee and labor relations across complex workforces, she writes about the human impact of business decisions, workplace culture, and the leadership responsibility to humanize work.
Reader Correspondence
Beneath the Headline explores the human impact behind business stories, examining how organizational decisions shape the experiences of employees and what leaders can learn from them.
Have a perspective to share, a question about this edition, or a business story you think deserves a closer look? Contact the author at hello@lashawndavis.me.