Beneath the Headline | Edition 005
The human impact behind the business story.
The Headline
Employees are increasingly uncertain about the skills they'll need as technology changes the way work gets done.
According to new research from WTW (formerly Willis Towers Watson), a global advisory firm specializing in people, risk, and capital, that uncertainty is creating what the firm calls capability anxiety: concern about whether employees' current skills will remain relevant and how they should prepare for what's next.
The research draws on responses from 7,000 employees across five countries and 549 employer organizations. It found that 78% of employees say their managers help develop their abilities, down from 84% four years earlier. Meanwhile, only about 30% of organizations have established processes for identifying, assessing, and tracking workforce skills.
Employees are being told to prepare for a future that many organizations haven't clearly defined themselves.
But there's something else beneath these findings that deserves attention.
As organizations become increasingly focused on which skills technology can replace, are they overlooking the value of the people who possess those skills?
Beneath the Headline
We've spent decades teaching people to demonstrate their professional value through what they can do. We encourage them to earn credentials, develop expertise, master systems, and build résumés that document their accomplishments. And there's nothing wrong with that. Skills matter. Experience matters. Professional development matters.
But somewhere along the way, we began confusing what people do with who they are.
When someone introduces themselves, they often begin with their job title. When organizations evaluate talent, they typically begin with job descriptions, competencies, and performance against assigned responsibilities.
Those approaches serve a purpose. But they don't necessarily tell us everything about the person performing the work.
Two employees can possess the same technical skills, hold the same position, and meet the same performance expectations, yet create entirely different experiences for the people around them.
Think about what changes when a particular person enters a room. The questions they ask. The problems they notice. The connections they make. The perspectives they introduce that no one else had considered.
Their presence changes the conversation, not simply because of what they've been trained to do, but because of how they think, what they've experienced, and the way they interpret the world around them.
That's value, too.
Consider an employee who has spent years coordinating complex operational processes. Technology is introduced that can now complete much of the administrative work previously occupying their day. The organization determines that certain responsibilities are no longer necessary and begins evaluating whether the position should continue to exist.
From an operational perspective, that evaluation makes sense.
But what happens to the employee's ability to anticipate problems, connect information across departments, recognize risks, or build relationships that help work get done? What happens to the judgment they've developed through years of navigating situations that don't fit neatly into a process?
Those capabilities may never have appeared in the job description, yet they may be among the most valuable contributions the employee makes.
A job description tells you what someone has been hired to do. It doesn't tell you everything they're capable of contributing.
And that's the distinction organizations need to understand as they redesign work.
The Human Impact
I've spent a great deal of time exploring a question that sounds simple but can be surprisingly difficult to answer:
Who are you outside of work?
Not what do you do for a living. Not what position do you hold. Not what credentials have you earned.
Who are you?
It's a question that invites people to recognize the qualities they bring into their work rather than allowing the work itself to define them.
Someone whose title is project manager may have a natural ability to create order from complexity. Someone in customer service may possess an exceptional ability to build trust and understand people. Someone working in an administrative role may have the curiosity and discernment to identify problems that others overlook.
These qualities aren't substitutes for technical skills, nor do they guarantee continued employment. But they influence how individuals apply their skills, approach challenges, and create value in ways that extend beyond their assigned responsibilities.
I often say, “Your identity was designed to produce your work. Your work was never designed to produce your identity.”
That distinction matters for employees questioning their professional futures. When people understand the value they bring beyond a particular task or position, they're better equipped to recognize how their capabilities might be applied elsewhere. They can develop new skills without believing they must become entirely different people to remain relevant.
But it also matters for the organizations making decisions about their futures.
If organizations have spent decades evaluating employees primarily through the work they're assigned, how much human potential have they overlooked simply because it didn't fit neatly into a job description?
An organization may have employees whose greatest contributions have never been formally identified because no one has taken the time to look beyond the work they were assigned.
And when those assignments change, that potential can disappear from the organization without anyone fully understanding what was lost.
Before It Becomes Your Headline
The WTW findings suggest that organizations have work to do in helping employees understand which capabilities will matter in the future. But that responsibility should extend beyond identifying technical skill gaps.
As executives consider how AI and automation will change their operating models, they should also examine whether their talent strategies recognize the full range of human capabilities already present in their workforces.
Before eliminating a position because technology can perform its primary responsibilities, organizations should ask a different question:
What do we know about the person occupying that position beyond the tasks we've assigned them?
If the answer is very little, perhaps the organization hasn't fully evaluated the talent it's preparing to lose.
This doesn't mean organizations should preserve positions that no longer serve a business need. It means understanding the people affected before concluding that eliminating their current responsibilities also means eliminating their potential contribution.
One practical place to begin is with the managers closest to the work.
Ask managers to identify employees whose contributions extend beyond their formal responsibilities. What problems do they consistently help solve? What strengths do colleagues rely on? What perspectives do they bring that improve decisions or help teams operate more effectively?
Then examine whether those capabilities could create value in other areas of the organization, particularly as new technology changes how work is performed.
That conversation should also include employees themselves. Ask what strengths they believe they bring, which responsibilities energize them, what interests they've had little opportunity to explore, and how they might want to contribute differently in the future.
These aren't replacements for workforce planning, skills assessments, or performance evaluations. They're ways to make those processes more informed.
In Edition 003, Your Employee Development Budget Is Underspent. Is That Good News?, I examined the difference between offering development opportunities and making investments employees can meaningfully use. The WTW research introduces another consideration: employees need more than access to development. They need direction, and organizations need a clearer understanding of the people they're developing.
For individuals, that process can begin with learning to recognize and articulate the value they bring beyond their professional titles. I've created a free reflection guide, Who Are You Outside of Work?, to help people begin exploring that question.
For organizations, the challenge is ensuring those capabilities don't remain invisible simply because they aren't captured in a job description or performance evaluation.
The Closing Thought
The WTW research identifies a real challenge. Employees are uncertain about the capabilities they'll need as work changes, and organizations are still developing the systems necessary to provide greater clarity.
But there's a larger risk in evaluating the future of work primarily through the tasks technology can perform. When organizations focus exclusively on which responsibilities can be automated, they may overlook the judgment, perspective, relationships, and potential of the people currently performing them.
Technology may change what people do. It may eliminate responsibilities, reshape positions, and require entirely new skills. But organizations should be careful not to confuse the value of a task with the value of the person performing it.
Because the work someone produces is only one expression of who they are. And when organizations fail to recognize the person beyond the profession, they may eliminate far more value than they intended.
Stay Human,
LaShawn Davis
About the Author
LaShawn Davis is the Founder and CEO of The HR Plug, an employee and labor relations advisory firm, and the creator of The UNPLUG Experience. Drawing on her experience advising organizations and leading employee and labor relations across complex workforces, she writes about the human impact of business decisions, workplace culture, and the leadership responsibility to humanize work.
Reader Correspondence
Beneath the Headline explores the human impact behind business stories, examining how organizational decisions shape the experiences of employees and what leaders can learn from them.
Have a perspective to share, a question about this edition, or a business story you think deserves a closer look? Contact the author at hello@lashawndavis.me.