Netflix Offered Michaela Coele $1 Million. What Did It Lose When She Said No?


Netflix Offered Her $1 Million. What Did It Lose When She Said No?

Beneath the Headline | Edition 006

The human impact behind the business story.

The Headline

Imagine being offered $1 million by Netflix to bring your creative work to its platform, and deciding to walk away. That's exactly what Michaela Coel did.

In 2017, Netflix offered the writer and creator approximately $1 million for her series I May Destroy You. Coel wanted to retain a portion of the copyright to her work. According to her account of the negotiations, she initially requested 5% ownership and eventually reduced that request to just 0.5%. The two parties never reached an agreement.

Coel went on to partner with the BBC, which offered an arrangement that allowed her to retain ownership and creative control. HBO later joined the production, and the series became a critical success, earning multiple awards, including an Emmy for Coel's writing.

Although the negotiations happened years ago, the story continues to resurface, usually as an example of someone knowing their worth and having the confidence to turn down a significant opportunity. I understand why people are drawn to that part of the story. A million dollars is a substantial offer, and Netflix is an established entertainment company with global reach. For many creators, an opportunity like that could be career-changing.

But every time I think about this story, I find myself considering the decision from the other side of the negotiating table.

Everyone is talking about the gamble Michaela Coel made by walking away from Netflix. What about the gamble Netflix made by letting her walk away?

Beneath the Headline

I think organizations sometimes become so accustomed to being desirable that they forget they still have to earn the interest and commitment of the people they want to work with.

Consider how much companies invest in building their brands. They want to be recognized as industry leaders, employers of choice, and places where talented people aspire to work. And there's certainly value in that reputation. But I wonder whether success can sometimes create a blind spot. When you've built a company that people recognize and admire, do you begin assuming that the opportunity to be associated with your organization should be enough?

Netflix was offering Coel a significant amount of money and access to an established platform. But she had her own priorities. Ownership of her work mattered to her, and she was willing to pursue another opportunity to protect it. We don't know why Netflix ultimately declined her request, and there may have been legitimate commercial considerations behind that decision. What we do know is that the company was willing to invest in her work, but the terms it offered weren't enough to secure her participation.

You can recognize someone's value without fully understanding what they value.

And I think that happens inside organizations more often than executives realize.

A company offers an employee a promotion because leadership believes it's a tremendous opportunity. The employee turns it down because the position would take them away from the work they enjoy. Another organization offers a higher salary to retain someone whose greatest concern is having more control over their schedule. A promising candidate declines an offer because the company won't reconsider a requirement that matters deeply to them.

From the organization's perspective, these may all appear to be attractive offers. But how often do leaders stop to consider whether they're offering what the person actually wants? And when the answer is no, how much effort goes into understanding why?

The Human Impact

There's another part of this story I think deserves attention.

Netflix has built an extraordinary business. But the success of an entertainment platform depends on more than the platform itself. It depends on the writers, filmmakers, actors, producers, and countless other people whose contributions give audiences a reason to watch.

The same is true for every organization. A retailer can build a recognizable brand, but employees influence the experiences that bring customers back. A technology company can develop sophisticated products, but people continue to generate the ideas, solve the problems, and identify the opportunities that keep the business moving forward.

Organizations become successful because people contribute something valuable to them. And maintaining that success requires continuing to attract people who can contribute to what comes next. That's why I find myself wondering whether established companies sometimes become more focused on what people gain from working with them than on what the organization stands to gain from those people.

I also wonder how differently these negotiations might have unfolded if Coel had already possessed the commercial influence of an Oprah Winfrey or Tyler Perry. We don't know the answer. But it's a question worth asking because organizations often express a desire to attract emerging talent and innovative thinkers while reserving their greatest flexibility for people who have already established themselves.

Are we willing to recognize someone's potential before the rest of the market confirms it? Or do we wait until they've become so successful that we're afraid of losing them?

Think about the people inside your own organization who have ideas they haven't had the opportunity to develop, capabilities that extend beyond their current responsibilities, or aspirations that don't fit the career paths you've created. What happens when those people begin asking for something different? Do we become curious about what they're trying to accomplish, or do we remind them of what the organization already provides?

And if they decide to leave, do we understand what we're losing? Because the consequences of losing someone aren't always immediate. Sometimes the person you were willing to let go becomes the innovator, leader, or creator another organization was willing to invest in.

Before It Becomes Your Headline

I don't believe organizations should agree to every request. There are legitimate business considerations, financial limitations, and operational requirements that influence what a company can accommodate. But I do believe executives should be more intentional about understanding what they're gambling with when they decide someone is worth losing.

Before you turn down a request, walk away from a negotiation, or accept the departure of someone you consider valuable, I'd encourage you to examine a few things.

Have you taken the time to understand what matters to this person? I'm talking about more than asking what salary they're expecting or what position they want next. What motivates them? What are they trying to accomplish? What would make the opportunity meaningful to them?

Are you making the decision based on the person's current standing or their future potential? Someone may not have the influence of an established industry leader today, but that doesn't mean they lack the ability to become one. How does your organization identify and support potential that hasn't yet been fully demonstrated?

How much of your decision is based on what you genuinely cannot do versus what you've simply never done before? Established practices serve a purpose, but they should still be examined when they become obstacles to attracting or retaining people whose contributions matter.

And perhaps most importantly, what are you prepared to lose if the person walks away?

I would encourage executives to make that last question part of their decision-making process. When a valued employee declines an opportunity, when a candidate requests something outside your standard offer, or when someone signals that they're considering leaving, don't immediately reduce the conversation to what the organization is willing to provide.

Ask what the person values, what the organization stands to gain from the relationship, and whether there's a reasonable way to bring those interests closer together. You may still decide the answer is no. But at least you'll understand the decision you're making and what may be at stake.

The Closing Thought

Michaela Coel's decision is easier to celebrate today because we know what happened afterward. I May Destroy You became an acclaimed series, and she received significant recognition for her work. At the time of the negotiations, neither party could have known exactly how the project would perform.

And that's what makes this story such an interesting leadership lesson.

Netflix was already Netflix. It had the brand, the audience, the resources, and the reputation. Those things gave the company considerable negotiating power, but they didn't guarantee that Coel would accept the terms being offered. She understood what mattered to her and chose an opportunity that aligned with it.

I think executives should remember that the people who contribute to an organization's success have priorities, ambitions, and standards of their own. An established company may have a great deal to offer, but that doesn't mean every talented person will consider the opportunity sufficient.

The more successful an organization becomes, the more important it is to remain curious about the people whose ideas and contributions will shape its future. Because the next breakthrough may come from someone who hasn't yet established a reputation, someone whose expectations challenge your usual practices, or someone who is willing to walk away because another organization understands what matters to them.

And when that happens, the organization may lose more than the opportunity to work with one individual. It may lose the chance to participate in something it couldn't yet see.

Before you decide someone is worth losing, ask yourself: What are you gambling with, and do you even know what's at stake?

Stay Human,

LaShawn Davis


About the Author

LaShawn Davis is the Founder and CEO of The HR Plug, an employee and labor relations advisory firm, and the creator of The UNPLUG Experience. Drawing on her experience advising organizations and leading employee and labor relations across complex workforces, she writes about the human impact of business decisions, workplace culture, and the leadership responsibility to humanize work.

Reader Correspondence

Beneath the Headline explores the human impact behind business stories, examining how organizational decisions shape the experiences of employees and what leaders can learn from them.

Have a perspective to share, a question about this edition, or a business story you think deserves a closer look? Contact the author at hello@lashawndavis.me.

11345 Tara Blvd. Suite 4-107, Hampton, GA 30248
​Unsubscribe · Preferences​

Beneath the Headline

Workplace headlines tell us what happened. We examine the decisions behind the story, the people affected, the warning signs overlooked, and what leaders can learn.

Read more from Beneath the Headline

The EEOC Changed Its Guidance. The History Hasn't Changed. What the withdrawal of criminal-history hiring guidance reveals about fairness, opportunity, and the standards employers choose to uphold. Beneath the Headline | Edition 008 The human impact behind the business story. The Headline On October 29, 2026, the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) announced that it had voted to withdraw its 2012 enforcement guidance on how employers consider arrest and conviction records when...

How Much Weight Should We Give Performance Reviews? When an annual evaluation influences someone's employment, executives need to examine more than the employee's rating. Beneath the Headline | Edition 007 The human impact behind the business story. The Headline Qualcomm is preparing to eliminate jobs globally following its annual employee performance reviews. According to an October 20 Reuters report, CEO Cristiano Amon informed employees that the company would undertake a...

Your Skills May Become Obsolete. But You Won't. Beneath the Headline | Edition 005 The human impact behind the business story. The Headline Employees are increasingly uncertain about the skills they'll need as technology changes the way work gets done. According to new research from WTW (formerly Willis Towers Watson), a global advisory firm specializing in people, risk, and capital, that uncertainty is creating what the firm calls capability anxiety: concern about whether employees' current...