Beneath the Headline | Edition 008
The human impact behind the business story.
The Headline
On October 29, 2026, the U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) announced that it had voted to withdraw its 2012 enforcement guidance on how employers consider arrest and conviction records when making employment decisions. The decision took effect immediately.
According to the EEOC's announcement, the agency maintains that Title VII of the Civil Rights Act continues to prohibit unlawful discrimination. The withdrawal also does not require organizations to abandon lawful hiring practices they adopted under the previous guidance.
EEOC Chair Andrea Lucas characterized the decision as an effort to enforce Title VII within the limits established by Congress and the Constitution.
But I have a serious concern about this decision, and it has everything to do with the history behind the guidance being withdrawn.
For decades, research and enforcement efforts have documented how criminal-history screening can reinforce racial disparities in access to employment. The EEOC's 2012 enforcement guidance drew on that history, including evidence of disproportionately high arrest and incarceration rates among Black and Hispanic Americans, to explain how seemingly neutral hiring practices could create discriminatory barriers to employment.
The EEOC can withdraw its guidance. It cannot erase the history that made the guidance necessary. And I believe that history deserves our attention before any employer considers changing its hiring practices.
Beneath the Headline
To understand why this decision matters, we need to understand why the guidance existed in the first place.
The EEOC had been addressing the discriminatory use of criminal records in employment decisions for decades, including through policy statements issued in 1987 and 1990. In 2012, the agency consolidated and expanded that guidance, recognizing that Black and Hispanic Americans experienced disproportionately high rates of arrest and incarceration and that employers' use of criminal-history screening could create barriers to employment for these populations.
The concern extended beyond employers who intentionally discriminated. It also involved disparate impact, which occurs when an employment practice appears neutral because it applies to everyone but disproportionately disadvantages a protected group without sufficient legal justification.
Consider an employer that automatically excludes every applicant with an arrest record. On the surface, the rule may appear fair because everyone is subject to the same standard. But an arrest is not proof that someone committed a crime. And when arrest rates are disproportionately higher among certain populations, applying that same rule to everyone can produce profoundly unequal outcomes.
Research has demonstrated how race and criminal history can intersect in employment decisions. In a 2003 study published in the American Journal of Sociology, sociologist Devah Pager found that white applicants presenting a criminal record received callbacks 17% of the time, compared with 14% for Black applicants without a criminal record. Even in this study, a white applicant with a criminal record was more likely to receive a callback than a Black applicant without one.
The 2012 guidance encouraged employers to recognize these distinctions. It explained why an arrest alone should not be treated as proof of criminal conduct, why convictions should be evaluated in relation to the responsibilities of a position, and how individualized consideration could help employers make more informed decisions.
It was guidance, not law. Employers still had legitimate safety concerns and business risks to consider. But the guidance recognized something that remains just as relevant today: equal treatment does not automatically create equal opportunity.
The EEOC may have withdrawn its guidance, but the history of systemic marginalization that informed it hasn't disappeared. And neither have the questions employers should be asking about the fairness of their hiring decisions.
The Human Impact
Imagine applying for a job you're qualified to perform. You have the experience, the skills, and the ability to contribute, but somewhere in your background is an arrest that never resulted in a conviction.
You were never found guilty of a crime, yet an employer sees the arrest and decides you're too much of a risk. You may never get the opportunity to explain what happened, and the organization may never discover what you could have contributed.
Now consider someone who was convicted of an offense years ago, completed their sentence, and has since worked to rebuild their life. Should that history automatically determine whether they're qualified for a position today?
I don't believe it should.
Organizations have legitimate responsibilities to protect employees, customers, and the business. There are positions where certain criminal conduct may present genuine, job-related risks, and employers should be able to consider those risks appropriately.
But there is a meaningful difference between evaluating an actual risk and making assumptions about someone's character, capabilities, or future behavior based solely on the existence of a record. And we should be particularly concerned when those assumptions operate within systems where access and opportunity have never been distributed equally.
An employment decision doesn't end when an applicant receives a rejection. It can affect their ability to earn a living, support their family, secure housing, and build a different future. For someone attempting to rebuild their life, meaningful employment can be an important part of that process.
When we discuss background screening, we often focus on the potential risk of hiring someone. I wonder whether we give equal consideration to the consequences of excluding someone who could have performed the job successfully.
That decision has a human cost. And depending on how an organization makes it, there may also be a cost to the business in talent, perspective, and opportunity lost.
Before It Becomes Your Headline
The EEOC's withdrawal of its guidance presents an important moment for executive leadership.
Organizations should understand the change and review its implications with their legal and HR teams. But I would caution against treating the withdrawal as an invitation to reverse hiring practices that were developed to support fair, informed decisions.
The EEOC has explicitly stated that employers are not required to abandon lawful practices adopted under the previous guidance. Title VII remains in effect, including its disparate-impact provisions, and applicable state and local fair-chance hiring requirements continue to matter.
So the question for executives becomes less about what the EEOC has withdrawn and more about what their organizations intend to uphold.
Understand why your current standards exist.
If your organization distinguishes arrests from convictions, considers the relationship between an offense and a position, or provides applicants an opportunity to explain relevant circumstances, understand why those practices were established.
Were they developed solely to respond to regulatory expectations, or do they reflect a broader commitment to fair, evidence-based hiring? And if leadership is considering changing those practices, what business or legal justification supports that decision?
Examine the outcomes your screening practices produce.
A policy can be consistently applied and still produce unequal outcomes. Executives should understand whether their screening criteria are genuinely related to the responsibilities of the position and whether qualified applicants are being unnecessarily excluded.
This requires more than confirming that everyone completed the same background check. It means examining the standards used to interpret the results, the discretion given to decision-makers, and whether those decisions are supported by relevant evidence.
Decide what standards your organization will uphold.
Many organizations publicly commit to fairness, opportunity, belonging, and treating people with dignity. Those commitments should be reflected in the decisions applicants actually experience, including decisions about who receives an opportunity to work.
Executives should be able to explain how their organizations balance legitimate safety concerns with access to employment, why particular screening criteria are necessary, and whether their hiring practices are consistent with the values they communicate publicly.
And if the organization decides to change its approach, leadership should be prepared to explain what has changed about the underlying business need or risk.
If the standards we claim to value change every time regulatory guidance changes, were they ever truly our standards?
The Closing Thought
I understand that regulatory agencies change their interpretations, priorities, and guidance. Organizations have to understand those changes and ensure their practices remain compliant with the law.
But I hope employers resist the temptation to interpret this withdrawal as a reason to abandon thoughtful hiring practices.
The 2012 guidance acknowledged something we should not lose sight of: people do not enter the employment process with equal access to opportunity. The consequences of seemingly neutral decisions can be very different depending on the history and circumstances of the people affected.
That reality should matter to leaders who are serious about fairness, regardless of which administration is in office or what guidance a federal agency chooses to maintain.
We cannot claim to value people while ignoring the systems and decisions that determine whether they ever receive an opportunity to contribute.
The EEOC changed its guidance. The history hasn't changed. And neither should our commitment to making fair, informed hiring decisions.
So here's the question I'd leave with executives:
When the government changes its guidance, will your organization change its values?
Stay Human,
LaShawn Davis
About the Author
LaShawn Davis is the Founder and CEO of The HR Plug, an employee and labor relations advisory firm, and the creator of The UNPLUG Experience. Drawing on her experience advising organizations and leading employee and labor relations across complex workforces, she writes about the human impact of business decisions, workplace culture, and the leadership responsibility to humanize work.
Reader Correspondence
Beneath the Headline explores the human impact behind business stories, examining how organizational decisions shape the experiences of employees and what leaders can learn from them.
Have a perspective to share, a question about this edition, or a business story you think deserves a closer look? Contact the author at hello@lashawndavis.me.